13 August, 2007
If we do not struggle
If we do not persist in our struggle
The enemy would finish us with his bayonets
And pointing to our bones he would tell the rest of the world
Look, these are bones of slaves !
Look, these are bones of slaves !!
( A Hindi couplet)
D Dhanraj from Tsundur ( Guntur, A.P.) possibly does not know how the rest of the world remembers 6 th of August. Neither possibly he knows that there is a city called Hiroshima in far away Japan which was nearly obliterated that day. But for him also the very day symbolises deaths and destruction and an endless wait for justice.
He can still recollect each and every incident on that fateful day way back in 1991 when five people from his own community were lynched before his eyes by a mob of marauders belonging to his village itself.
In fact, the blood thirsty mob had nearly lynched him also but somehow he was saved. Streets of Tsundur that day witnessed deaths of total eight people all of them dalits when a 400 strong armed mob of Reddys – a landlord caste which has dominated the politics of A.P since independence – attacked the dalits to teach them a lesson. The perpetrators of the massacre were so brutal that they cut the dead bodies into pieces, put them in gunny bags and threw them in the nearby Tungabhadra canal.
But as of now the wait for justice seems to be finally over. The recent judgement of the Special Court – which was the first of its kind formed under the provisions of the SC and ST Act (1989) at the scene of offence- has rather vindicated their sixteen year old struggle. Twenty one of the accused have been given life imprisonment which 35 of the accused have been asked to serve one year rigorous imprisonment. The court have acquitted the rest of the accused showing lack of evidence, but a coalition of dalit organisations have been pressing upon the government to file a petition in the upper court to challenge the acquttal.
A brief recap of the events in this ‘historic case’ tells us that the upper caste ( read Reddys’ ) used the pretext of of alleged harassment of a Reddy girl by a dalit youth in a cinema hall to attack the dalits. The planned nature of the attack was evidnt also from the fact that within no time a few hundred strong mob of Reddys wielding traditional weapons (and few of them carrying modern firearms) descended on the dalit hamlett and unleashed their fury against the innocents. In fact, sensing an imminent attack, most of the menfolk had alread left the village. Once the marauders came to know of this they literally chased the dalits on the road adjoining the Tungabhadra canal and lynched them one by one.
Looking back it is clear that the preplanned attack against the dalits was another futile attempt by the Reddys to reassert their age-old authority which had seen fissures with the growing assertion of dalits. The changed atmosphere in the village was for everyone to see.Not only many of the dalits boys and girls had benefitted from the affirmative action programmes in education, a few among them had even surpassed the Reddys in many respects. Many of the dalits from the village were working with Indian Railways. Overall the situation was such that the Dalits had refused to follow the medieval dictats reserved for them under the Varna system.
D Dhanraj was a crucial witness to the whole case. He did not falter for a moment despite tremendous pressure brought upon him by the powerful Reddys.One can see that Tsundur, the small village in Guntur, has created many such ‘unsung heroes’ – ordinary looking people who faced heavy odds so that they get justice. Merukonda Subbarao, a fifty six year old daily wage-worker, who had served as the first president of the Tsunduru Victims Association was another such ‘hero’ who identified and named forty of the accused standing in the court room, from among the one hundred and eighty three accused. It was clear that the whole incident was etched in his memory so strongly that he did not falter despite the judges requests to repeat the identification. And who can forget Martyr Anil Kumar, a young man in his twenties who was in the forefront of the struggle so that the perpetrators of the massacre are punished without delay. Anil was killed in a police firing during one of those struggles.
As is clear in every other atrocity against the dalits, the Reddys who have dominated the state politics since independence, tried with all their might so that they are allowed to go scot free. Utilising their contacts in the Judiciary, bureacracy or police administration they tried to delay the process of justice as long as they could do it.
Attempts were made to buy or coerce the dalits in very many ways and the state also tried to play second fiddle to the Reddy’s. It felt that by distributing largesse to the dalits, giving jobs to few of them, awarding compensation to the victims families they could calm down their yearning for justice. But dalits in Tsundur wanted nothing less than severe punishment for the perpetrators.Unitedly they raised a slogan ‘Justice not Welfare’. It was worth emphasising that with their continued resistance they were able to make Tsundur a key issue in state politics.
Any independent observer of the dalit situation in the country – who has been watching with awe the spurt in cases of dalit atrocities at a national level – would note the fact that the conviction of the perpetrators at Tsundur is a significant milestone in the ongoing dalit emancipation movement.
The nearly sixty year old history of independent India bears witness to this phenomenon where perpetrators of crimes against dalits in majority of the cases were allowed to go scot free. The mechanism for denial of justice to dalits has rather been perfected down the years Normally such cases are either not registered and if at all they get registred they are not filed under appropriate provisions of the law. Registration of cases under proper law is no guarantee that they would be investigated by designataed authority in such cases. The result is for everyone to see acquittal on flimsy grounds.
A conclusion of a detailed and systematic study of 400 judgements passed by different district courts of Gujarat done by Vajibhai Patel, Secretary of Council for Social Justice corroborates this. It tells us that utterly negligent police investigation at both the higher and lower levels coupled with a distinctly hostile role played by the public prosecutors is the main reason for the collapse of cases filed under the atrocities act. It is worth noting that he has meticulously documented these judgements delivered under this act since April 1, 1995 in the Special Atrocity Courts set up in 16 districts of the state. The study also blasts the common perception is that the inefficacy of this law is due to false complaints being lodged or compromises between the parties, in actuality it is a complicit State that has rendered the Act toothless.(Communalism Combat’ March 2005)
People would recollect that in an inter state council meet called by the Prime Minister to deliberate on the specific issue of dalit rage, the Prime Minister himself had lamented the fact that (The Hindu, 10 th December 2006) ‘implementation of SC and ST(Prevention of Atrocities) Act has not been effective’ and ‘cases continue to be registered under weaker sections of IPC’.
A convention held last year under the aegis of the social justice minister (Jan 2005) Meira Kumar which was duly attended by the home minister had brought home this point with emphasis. According to a newspaper report :
“Social justice minister Meira Kumar pointed out that the conviction rate in cases registered under the Protection of Civil Rights Act is a mere 3.75 per cent. Besides, 75 to 77 per cent cases of crimes against Dalits remain pending despite the existence of special and designated courts. (January 12, 2005, The Telegraph)
It is possible that all this details where the state and its different organs comes out in rather unflattering terms could be brushed aside as a story repeated ad nauseam. All the talk of dalit atrocities could be presented as another extension of the way in which ‘state in the third world’ unfolds itself. But the key point worth emphasising is that caste atrocities much like gender oppression or racial atrocities have a specificity which transcends the binary of ‘state as perpetrator’ and ‘people as victims’ . In fact they implicate the partisan role played by the people themselves.
The ‘Report on Prevention of Atrocities against SCs ‘ prepared by NHRC ( 2004) presents details of the way in which the civil society presents itself . Here civil society itself becomes a distinct beneficiary of caste based order and helps perpetuate the existing unequal social reactions and frustrates attempts to democratize the society because through the customary arrangements the dominant classes are assured of social control over people who can continue to abide by their commands without any protest.
Of course the uncivil nature of the civil society presents before us a unique challenge where the need then becomes to rise above a mere discourse on civil and constitutional rigths and address the failure of the largest democracy of the world to go beyond mere form. We have to appreciate that it concerns the greater hiatus that exists between constitutional principles and practice and corresponding ethical ones based on a diametrically opposed ideal.
Everyone has to see that under the purity and pollution based paradigm which is the cornerstone of our caste system, inequality receives not only legitimisation as well as sanctification. As inequality is accepted both in theory and practice, a legal constitution has no bearing on the ethical foundation of caste-based societies.In fact Dr Ambedkar, the legendary leader of the oppressed had this very reality in his minds, when he emphasised the difference between what he called ‘political democracy’ and ’social democracy’, the difference between ‘one person having one vote’ and ‘one person having one value’.
It would not be an exaggeration to say that the victory of the Dalits in Tsundur is ‘historic’ in very many ways :
– It demonstrated the immense possibilities inherent in the SC and ST Prevention of Atrocities Act (1989) which till date remain on paper. As rightly noted by many analysts it is the first time in the nearly twenty year old trajectory of this act that special courts had to be set up at the scene of offence. And the dalits were saved from travelling long distances to depose in the courts and face harassment on the way at the hands of the dominant castes.
It is noteworthy that Dalits in Tsundur were so united that neither they accepted any summons from the courts nor they just ever went to court which was situated at some distanct place from the village. They demanded in unison that the courts should come to them and the government had to concede to their demand and set up special courts in a school premises.
– They also demanded that they be provided with a Public Prosecutor and a judge who has a positive track record while dealing with cases of dalit atrocities. After lot of dilly-dallying the government complied with this demand also.
– It has been normal in all such cases of dalit atrocities that as time passes, people including victims and their families loose interest in continuing their fight for justice. They come under pressure or are coerced into changing their statement in the courts etc. We have before us the recent verdict in Kambalapalli massacre of Dalits in Karnataka where the witnesses – those very people who had lost their near and dear ones – themselves turning hostile leading to acquittal of the accused.
The significance of the Tsundur struggle was that the people leading the campaign were successful in keeping the people mobilised all these years. Ofcourse the help rendered by dalit as well as left organisations also played an important role in keeping the flame alive. Tsundur became a rallying point for different left and democratic forces in the state and it was harbinger of a new turn in the left politics also which resolved to take up the issue of caste oppression.
As rightly noted by an analyst the victory ( albeit a partial one) at Tsundur has come as breath of fresh air in the already smouldering world of dalit oppression. And it is high time that its fragrance is spread far and wide, so that people are told that oppressed people united would always be victorious.
People who have visited Tsundur would tell you that there is a ‘Raktakshetram’ in Tsundur – a place in the centre of the Dalit basti where the massacred Dalits were cremated. Till date it has remained as a live reminder of the atrocity only. But post-verdict one can say that it has metamorphosed into a symbol of their yearning to live a life of dignity and getting ready to make tremendous sacrifices to make it happen.